Dubinsky Life & Legacydubinskylife.com
310-614-5636
Know before you buy

The Impact of AI on Insurance Sales

AI might be the first voice you hear when you ask for a quote. Here is what it does, what it can’t do, and how to tell a real insurance office from a scammer.

8 min readBy Perry Dubinsky, licensed agent

Key takeaways

  • AI handles the busywork: first contact, basic questions, scheduling and call notes.
  • Advice, quotes and the application still come from a licensed agent. The insurance company decides approval and price.
  • An AI call about insurance should follow something you did, like requesting a quote.
  • Never give your Social Security, bank or card numbers on an AI call. Verify any agent with your state Department of Insurance.

Why the first voice may not be a person

If you’ve asked for a life insurance quote lately, there’s a good chance the first voice you heard wasn’t a person. It was an AI assistant. That catches a lot of people off guard, and I understand why. Between robocalls and scam texts, most of us have learned to be suspicious of any call we didn’t expect.

I’m a licensed life insurance agent, and I use AI in my business. So I want to walk you through what it is, what it does for me, what it does for you, and how to tell a real insurance office from a scammer.

What AI actually is

Start with what AI actually is. The tools insurance offices use are called large language models. They’ve been trained on an enormous amount of written text, and from that they learned how language works well enough to hold a conversation, answer a simple question, or summarize a phone call. That’s really all it is. It doesn’t know anything about you until you tell it. It can’t sign a contract, it can’t approve a policy, and it can’t make promises on behalf of an insurance company. I think of it as an assistant who has read every training manual but has never met a client.

Who's on the other end

It also helps to know who’s on the other end. Agents aren’t a bunch of used car salesmen running around. Life insurance is one of the most heavily regulated businesses in the country, and every agent answers to the state. Before I can help you, all of this has to be in place:

  • A state license. Every state requires one to sell insurance. Agents pass a state exam and, in most states, a background check before they can write a single policy.
  • A license in your state. An agent must hold a license in the state where you live. If you live in Ohio, your agent needs an Ohio license.
  • A National Producer Number (NPN). Every licensed agent has one. It follows them across states and careers.
  • Continuing education. Agents must complete ongoing training to keep their license active.
  • Carrier appointments. Insurance companies vet agents before allowing them to submit business, including performing a comprehensive background check.
  • Anti-Money Laundering (AML) Training. Agents must complete training in how to recognize, prevent, and report attempts to use insurance products for money laundering.
  • Errors and omissions coverage. Professional agents carry their own insurance in case they make a mistake.
  • A regulator watching. Your state Department of Insurance takes complaints, investigates misconduct, and can suspend or revoke a license.

The rules AI has to follow

Regulators have caught up to AI as well. In December 2023 the National Association of Insurance Commissioners put out a model bulletin on how insurers can use AI, and roughly half the states plus Washington, DC have adopted it. Their position is straightforward: the same insurance laws apply whether a person or a piece of software does the work.

The phone rules are strict too. In February 2024 the FCC ruled that AI-generated voices count as “artificial” voices under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act. That means a company generally needs your consent before an AI voice can call you. If an AI assistant calls you about insurance, it should be because you filled out a form or asked for a quote.

Have a question about a call you got? A 15 minute call with a licensed agent answers it.

What the AI actually does

So what does the AI actually do? Mostly the work a junior associate or office assistant used to handle. It answers when you first reach out. It confirms your name, your state, and a good time to talk. It asks a few basic questions so I have some background before we meet. It books the appointment, sends the reminder, and writes up notes from the call.

Everything that takes a license still comes to me. I explain your options, run quotes with the carriers, recommend what fits your situation and budget, and complete the application with you. The insurance company makes the final call on approval and price. AI doesn’t touch any of that.

What it means for you, and for me

For you, this means less waiting and less repeating yourself. You’ll usually hear back within minutes instead of days. You answer the basic questions once, and they reach me in writing, so our meeting can start with your options instead of your date of birth. Rescheduling is a text away.

For me, it means more of my day goes to actual advice and less to data entry. I show up prepared, I’m less likely to miss a detail, and I can help more families without shortchanging any of them. Nobody gets into this work because they love paperwork.

What happens to your words after an AI call

Here’s what happens to your words after an AI call. The call is recorded, and a legitimate assistant will tell you that up front. Speech recognition software converts the audio to text, the same technology behind the captions on your phone. Then the AI reads the transcript and pulls out what matters: your age, your state, what you want the coverage to do, a rough coverage amount, any big health factors, and when you’re free to talk. Those details land in a short profile in my secure customer system. Before we meet, I read it and note anything I need to ask you about.

A typical summary might read: Jane, 42, lives in Ohio, non-smoker, takes blood pressure medication, wants enough coverage to pay off the mortgage and replace her income for her two kids, thinking around $500,000, free weekday evenings after 6. You won’t find a Social Security number, bank account, or card number in there. Those never belong in a call summary.

Speech recognition is good, but it isn’t perfect. It can mishear a name or a number. That’s one more reason I go over the details with you myself.

Questions you'll likely hear on the first call

If you want to be ready for that first call, these are the questions you’re most likely to hear:

  • What state do you live in, and how old are you?
  • Is the coverage for you, your spouse, or both?
  • What got you thinking about life insurance now?
  • Are you trying to cover a mortgage, replace your income, handle final expenses, or leave something behind?
  • Do you have a coverage amount or a monthly budget in mind?
  • Do you already have life insurance, through work or on your own?
  • Are you married, and does anyone depend on your income?
  • Do you own your home, and roughly what’s left on the mortgage?
  • Do you use tobacco or nicotine?
  • About how tall are you, and what do you weigh?
  • Do you take any regular medications or have any major health conditions?
  • When is a good time for the agent to call?

The health questions are kept general on purpose. They help me figure out which insurance companies are likely to treat you best. Your full medical history goes on the official application later. And if you’d rather not answer something, just say you’d like to talk about it with the agent. That’s completely fine.

It helps to have a few things nearby: your medication list, your mortgage balance, any policy you already have, and a monthly number you’re comfortable with.

What to share, and what to keep

As for what you should and shouldn’t share, my rule is simple. If it helps me prepare, it’s fine. If someone could use it to open an account, move money, or pretend to be you, it waits for the secure application.

Fine to share by text or on an AI call: your name, state, age, and the best time to reach you; what you want the coverage to do and roughly what you want to spend; whether you’re married and have kids; tobacco use, height, and weight; and health conditions and medications in general terms.

Save for the application with your agent: your full date of birth, home address, and driver’s license number.

Never give on an AI call or by text: your Social Security number, bank account or routing number, or credit and debit card numbers. Those go only through the secure application or the carrier’s payment system. And nobody legitimate, not me and not any insurance company, will ever ask for your password, your PIN, or a code sent to your phone.

If an AI assistant asks for any of those, hang up. Then call the agent’s office back on a number you looked up yourself.

How to tell a real office from a scammer

Scammers use AI too, which is exactly why the FCC tightened the rules. A real insurance office is pretty easy to recognize. The call follows something you did, like requesting a quote. The assistant says who it’s calling for and lets you know the call is recorded. It sticks to basic questions, and the goal is a conversation with a licensed agent, not a payment on the spot.

Be suspicious of anyone who pressures you to decide today, asks for a gift card or wire transfer, won’t tell you which agency or agent they work for, or calls from a company you’ve never heard of about a quote you never requested.

If you’re not sure, ask for the agent’s full name, their license number or NPN, and the state they’re licensed in. A legitimate office will give you that without hesitating. Then look it up on your state Department of Insurance website.

The bottom line

AI didn’t replace your agent. It replaced the busywork. If an AI assistant calls after you request a quote, treat it like a good receptionist: answer the basics, keep your sensitive numbers for the secure application, and verify the agent if anything feels off.

That’s how I use it at Dubinsky Life & Legacy. AI helps me respond faster and come to our meeting prepared. The advice, the quotes, and the application all come from me, a licensed agent.

Common questions

Is it legal for an AI assistant to call me about insurance?

In February 2024 the FCC ruled that AI-generated voices count as artificial voices under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act. A company generally needs your consent first, so an AI call should follow a form you filled out or a quote you asked for.

Can an AI assistant sell me a policy?

No. It can't sign a contract, approve a policy, or make promises on behalf of an insurance company. The advice, the quotes and the application come from a licensed agent, and the insurance company makes the final call on approval and price.

What should I never share on an AI call?

Your Social Security number, bank account or routing number, or credit and debit card numbers. Those go only through the secure application or the carrier's payment system. Nobody legitimate will ever ask for your password, your PIN or a code sent to your phone.

How do I know an agent is real?

Ask for the agent's full name, their license number or NPN, and the state they're licensed in. A legitimate office will give you that without hesitating. Then look it up on your state Department of Insurance website.

Sources

I wrote this article with help from AI tools for research and editing. I reviewed every word, and the views and advice are my own.

Perry Dubinsky, licensed insurance agent
Meet your agent

Questions? Ask a real person.

I am Perry Dubinsky, a licensed agent. I will compare options from top carriers and help you choose what fits, with no pressure and no cost to talk.

Worksheet

How much coverage do you need?

Fill in your own numbers with our two page worksheet. We will email it to you.

We will send the worksheet and an occasional note from Perry. No spam, and you can unsubscribe anytime.
Questions? Call Perry Dubinsky at 310-614-5636 or visit dubinskylife.com/talk-to-an-agent

This guide is general education, not advice for your specific situation. Coverage, pricing, features and availability vary by insurance company, state, age and health. Riders and living benefits are subject to policy terms and may not be available in every state. Perry Dubinsky is a licensed insurance agent, dba Dubinsky Life & Legacy, NPN 22240311.

Perry Dubinsky, licensed insurance agent, dba Dubinsky Life & Legacy | NPN 22240311

FL #G346163 · TX #3506376 · WA #1364462 · CA #4592723 · Also licensed in MD, MI, MO, NM, OH, SC, TN, VA